|Senuke vs TrafficRex vs SEO Power Suite vs IBP
SEO reviews, which is the best SEO service?
Experiment Aim: Which SEO service gives the fastest results?
Note: We are not affiliated in any way with the experimented products.
To find out which is the most effective SEO product we have decided to setup a test to measure the results of different SEO services and softwares.
For this experiment, we have set up a 4 brand new websites marketing same products, we have chosen a niche with average competition and duplicated the content through all 4 sites. Products are selling at price range of $9.00 – $47.95 for each site.
Choice of keywords: For the experiment, we have chosen 3 keyphrases variated with different difficulty levels. All 4 sites will be optimized with our chosen sets of keywords.
Easy level Keyphrase 1:
390 monthly searches with 187,000 competing results. < should be easy to rank on page 1 of Google. < should be a piece of cake for any SEO software.
Intermediate level Keyphrase 2:
170 monthly searches with 1,850,000 competing results. < we have determined the difficulty of this keyphrase as intermediate as resulting sites is over 1,500,000.
Difficult level Keyphrase 3:
170 monthly searches with 31,400,000 competing results. < we have determined the difficulty of this keyphrase as highly difficult as resulting sites is over 31 million. We assumed that non of the services we are about to put to test could rank this keyphrase on any pages of google in our 30 days test.
We have tested 4 popular SEO services and products and we would like to share the results.
||SEO Power Suite
||Online SEO Service that builds backlinks
||SEO, Backlinking Software
Note: Do check out the latest pricing of each services by visiting their links.
SEO Services Case Study
Senuke: SE Nuke spins articles and automatically submits it to many article directories for a quick back link, also it automatically does social bookmarking for you.
TrafficRex: A SEO solution that generates targeted traffic through relevant backlinks building and via other forms of marketing strategies. Unlike many other SEO services or softwares, their goal is to help clients build high quality backlinks that improves targeted traffic and search engines rankings.
They don’t just build links, they build links that drive real targeted traffic that will convert to sales. Well, at least that’s what they claimed they will do. >> “Targeted traffic that converts.”
IBP: iBusiness Promoter provides useful tools for building your SEO program. It has a full set of keyword optimization tools and link building tools. It also helps you analyze your competition’s links and websites. It does have its drawbacks, including the fact that it limits the number of projects you can have at one time to five. Most of the other top SEO software packages we reviewed allow you to conduct an unlimited number of projects at one time.
SEO Power Suite: SEO PowerSuite is made up of four software tools in one pack that, when put together, guarantee you leadership in search engines and new streams of visitors. You can check out all SEO tools one by one, and decide to invest in just one or two out of four for the good start. Or get the full SEO PowerSuite and take advantage of the complete website promotion software set.
Web Statistics After 30 Days
Site managed by SE NUKE
Traffic Generated 30 days after implementing Senuke
Results of Senuke after 30 days
Senuke: Software runs for entire 30 days, building links and comments.
Results show 0 keyword phrases generated 3 unique visitors. Maybe it’s still too early to judge.
We assumed that links built were of low quality or spammy, no improved rankings, and only 3 visitors which seem like it is generated by bots.
Site managed by TRAFFICREX
Traffic Generated 30 days after implementing TrafficRex
Results of TrafficRex after 30 days
TrafficRex: Everything on auto-pilot and managed by their SEO team.
TrafficRex generated over 493 unique visitors and via 71 different keyphrases.
Statistics look good, but we have further analysis to do. Read on…
Site managed by SEO Power Suite
Traffic Generated 30 days after implementing SEO Power Suite
Results of SEO Power Suite after 30 days
SEO Power Suite service gives quite a good decent result, with 16 different keyphrases that resulted 64 unique visitors. Results considered good for the first 30 days. Read on…
Site managed by IBP
Traffic Generated 30 days after implementing IBP
Results of IBP after 30 days
Results of IBP looks average on the stats,
despite following their SEO recommendations and scoring 90% on their checklist, they are not bringing better results than other cheaper
Rankings >> Results are in!
As we know it is easy for any SEO services to fake web statistics,
by checking out the rankings will help us better determine which service actually delivers real results.
|Checking the rankings of our 1st Easiest to optimize keyphrase.
Keyphrase with 390 monthly searches, with only 187,000 competing results on Google US.Ranking Results:
Both Trafficrex and SEO Power Suite managed to rank the page on page 1 of Google within the first 30 days. The other 2 sites managed by IBP and Senuke were found on page 2 and 8 of Google.Senuke ranked the site on Page 8 at position #2, IBP ranked the site on Page 2 at position #2.
|Checking the rankings of our 2nd keyphrase > intermediate level.
Keyphrase with 170 monthly searches, with 1,850,000 competing results on Google US.Ranking Results:
IBP, TrafficRex and SEO Power Suite managed to rank the site on page 1 of Google within the first 30 days. We could not find the site managed by Senuke on first 10 pages of Google for the same keyphrase.
|Checking the rankings of our 3rd keyphrase > Highly difficult keyphrase.
Keyphrase with 170 monthly searches, with 31,400,000 competing results on Google US.Ranking Results:
All services did not rank any of their managed sites on page 1 of Google within the first 30 days.However, 2 of our tested services TrafficRex and SEO Power Suite ranked the test sites on page 2 and page 3 of Google for the given keyphrase. Site by TrafficRex on page 2, #1 and Site by SEO PowerSuite on page 3, #1.
Sites optimized by both IBP and Senuke could not be found on first 10 pages of Google for the given keyphrase.
Traffic Relevancy Check
Since the products are sold via a different clickbank accounts,
we will check on number of hops each site has generated to further
determine if traffic driven are targeted.
Above: Total of 271 Hops generated by site optimized by TrafficRex
Above: Total of 10 Hops generated by site optimized by SEO PowerSuite
2 other accounts received zero hops.
From the results above, it seems that TrafficRex is producing better results than 3 other services we are experimenting with.
Finally… Checking on Sales…
Sales Stats = True Results!
All Sites’ Products priced at $9.00 – $47.95
Talking is cheap, even by looking at all the statistics could not determine the reliability of the experimented SEO services since every single stat can be manipulated in some ways.The ultimate way to determine the best service is by looking at how many sales eachof these services has generated. Well, maybe it is still not the best way. But hey, when wepay for SEO, we ultimately want sales to be driven. Not just links, not just rankings,and not just great looking stats!
We didn’t expect that any of the experimented SEO services could deliver such results(sales) until we login to all 4 clickbank accounts and was pretty much surprised by the results!
Here’s what we saw
Site Optimized By TrafficRex resulted $485.61
Site Optimized By SEO PowerSuite resulted $35.08
Summary of Results
30 Days SEO Test
SENUKE > 3 Visitors via 0 keyphrase > 0 CB Hops > 0 Sales
TrafficRex > 493 Visitors via 71 keyphrases > 271 CB Hops > Sales of $485.61
SEO PowerSuite > 64 Visitors via 16 keyphrases > 10 CB Hops > Sales of $35.08
IBP > 43 Visitors via 2 keyphrases > 0 CB Hops > 0 Sales
Verdict for Senuke:
Senuke is packed with loads of features and constantly updated with the latest seo algorithms. During our first 30 days test, SE Nuke did not perform as expected or maybe it is just too early to experience good results with Senuke. However, our aim of this experiment is to find out which SEO service/product can deliver fastest result. In this case, senuke failed in our first 30 days experiment.
Verdict for TrafficRex
TrafficRex is marketed as a premium SEO service at a low price. Most of the SEO, backlinkings are manually done by their team (real humans) and statistics are constantly monitored by the team. In comparison of all statistics and results, they passed our test with flying colors!
Verdict for SEO PowerSuite
Another great SEO software jammed packed with several professional SEO tools, it is a little pricey but does deliver good results. We believed that even better results can be experienced with this piece of software. Yes, we recommend this stuff!
Verdict for IBP
IBP seems to deliver some good traffic, we do expect to see better results if we give it a longer timeframe. Since this software is a one-time off investment, we do recommend this as well.
Winner for our first 30 day SEO Test
2nd Place Winner
Tell us what you think?